Sunday, September 19, 2010

Talk Moves- Amy Benson

Though I thought this week’s reading was helpful, I was a little surprised by the topic. Since we are being taught to teach in a “new age”, I feel like a lot of these strategies have already been engrained in us. I didn’t realize that these strategies had categories and names; I simply thought that education was moving in a more student led direction in general, and that over time teaching has reflected these changes. It is hard for me to choose one strategy that stood out to me the most, as I think the chapter illustrated that they all seem to flow smoothly together. I think the strategy that comes the LEAST naturally for me is Wait Time. I’ve heard over and over again, from countless CT’s, that it is so important to develop Wait Time. As a new teacher, I think the idea of Wait Time is a little scary. It all sounds great, but when you’re actually doing it, it feels like failure. It is hard to allow the room to sit in silence for minutes without feeling like you must have done something wrong or not explained something clearly enough (I actually think Wait Time is also a great, but somewhat unnatural, strategy for classroom management as well). The talk move that seems the most natural to me is Adding On. I think that I am always pretty conscious of which students have spoken during discussion and which students haven’t, and I’m always trying to make sure that everyone has a turn. I think it is important to make sure that every student feels like an important part of the conversation and that the rest of the class is interested in what they have to say. I really like that Chapin highlighted the importance of establishing a classroom community in which “all students have the opportunity to engage in productive talk about mathematics”.

2 comments:

  1. Amy,

    I really like the way you thought about the readings this week. Through your ideas, I am now rethinking some of my original thoughts regarding talk moves in general. When I was reading Chapin, I also thought that Wait Time was the most foreign and uncomfortable, if you will, talk move for me to use. I think a lot of my feeling regarding it comes from being uncomfortable with standing up in front of a class silently waiting for someone to raise their hand. I always feel the need to interrupt and say something that will spark students thinking if I have noticed that there is little to no response or participation. So... I totally understand what you are saying about the talk move Wait Time in general. I also like the way you talk about creating an all inclusive environment during classroom discussions. I agree that it is extremely important and beneficial when students know that they are an important of class discussions. That way, students feel more comfortable and we work to establish a community of learners, which at the end of the day (in my eyes) is the most important part of being a teacher.

    Great post!
    Kendall :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. I will have to agree with both of you when I say that Wait Time was one of the more unnatural/uncomfortable talk moves for me. However, I can see how it can be used as a classroom management tool...when students begin to notice that the teacher is not doing what he/she is normally doing at the front of the room (discussing or leading a lesson, describing an activity, etc), they'll begin to feel that what they are doing is what is preventing the teacher from doing what they should be doing. I find its a good technique, but definitely one that will take me a while to feel comfortable implimenting into my teaching style. Amy, what are some of the ways that you would make sure that every student is actively participating in your classroom discussions? How do you engage those students that are shy, quiet, and never raise their hand? How would you make sure the rest of the class is truly interested in what another student has to say?
    Great post, girls! See you tomorrow!
    -Emily

    ReplyDelete